A reader of one of the better vegan cannoli recipes rolled her dough thin with a rolling pin and again through a pasta maker, fried the shells in vegan shortening, and still got something soft. “More like a thin cannonchini. What could be the reason?” That recipe lists water, sparkling water or wine as interchangeable, and she had not used wine. That one choice is most of the answer, and the page never told her so.
The filling fails differently. Two readers of the same recipe reported opposite results, one who never got the thickness she wanted and one who wrote that after a couple of hours in the fridge hers “was perfect.” Same instructions, different chill time. Both problems have numbers attached, and the numbers are below, sourced the same way as the rest of the vegan recipes here.
Vegan cannoli filling starts with a drained curd
Dairy ricotta is curd with the liquid taken out, and the vegan version works the same way. Nico Pallotta and Louise at The Plant Based School publish the formula in their video description: 3 liters of unsweetened soy milk, 7 tablespoons of apple cider vinegar and a little salt, strained through cheese cloth.
The acid does the work. A USDA Agricultural Marketing Service report on tofu coagulants puts it in a line: “The gradual acidification produced by the GDL initiates the curdling of the protein.” Vinegar in hot soy milk is the fast version of that reaction, which is why the same move underpins most homemade vegan cheese. The coagulant also decides texture, so tofu types are not swappable here. Silken tofu is set with glucono delta-lactone, while House Foods lists its extra firm block as “Water, Soybeans, Calcium Sulfate, Calcium Chloride.”

Whatever base you pick, the water comes out before the sugar goes in. Pallotta drains his ricotta base under a weight for 15 to 30 minutes. Jasmine Briones at Sweet Simple Vegan presses tofu instead and says skipping it is what leaves a filling loose. House Foods tells buyers to “press for better texture” and gives 10 to 15 minutes, though it states that time for browning rather than for a filling that has to hold a shape. Treat it as the floor and keep pressing while the block weeps.
Five tested fillings here use five different bases, and they agree on two things. All five use powdered or confectioners sugar and none uses granulated, and none adds cornstarch, tapioca or any other stabiliser. Chilling is what sets it. Nasoya says to blend and “place in the fridge to set for 1 hour.” Give it an hour before you judge it and two before you call it a failure. A starch might work, but nobody in this set has tested one, so I am not going to hand you an amount.
Vegan cream cheese thins a warm filling because of what is in it. Tofutti leads with “Water, Palm Oil, Maltodextrin” and finishes with locust bean, guar and xanthan gums. Water, fat and gums, held in shape by being cold. The allergy split matters too: Tofutti states it contains soy and the Kite Hill almond version states it contains almonds, so a dairy free cannoli can dodge tree nuts or soy, not both.
If you go the cashew route, soak the cashews in the fridge. A 2024 Food Protection Trends study from Purdue and UC Davis, which read 505 consumer recipes for nut based dairy analogs, found that “soaking tree nuts at lower temperatures (<15 C) prevents pathogen growth within a 24-h soaking period,” and that only 9 percent of those recipes said to do it. Salting or acidifying the soak water at home levels does not stand in for the cold.
Vegan cannoli shells need acid in the dough
Blisters are the point of a cannoli shell. Marie Pinto Bialek at Feeling Foodish, who is not writing a vegan recipe but is the clearest source on the physics, describes them: “The bubbling occurs as moisture in the dough turns to steam during frying.” On the ingredient side she credits the vinegar with helping “create air bubbles for texture” and the marsala with acidity and flavor.
Louise gave the substitution ratio when a reader asked: “Mix 1 tablespoon vinegar + 3 tablespoons water (this replaces the 4 tablespoons wine). This keeps the acidity in the dough.” That is the fix for the soft shell report at the top of this page. Plain water carries no acid and the shell has nothing to blister with.
The doughs are lean and small. Pallotta’s is 200 g of cake flour, 25 g of sugar, 25 g of vegan butter, 65 g of wine, 15 g of water, a teaspoon of dark cacao and half a teaspoon of cinnamon. Asked whether all purpose can stand in for cake flour, Louise answered yes, and said the shells “will still work; they’ll just be a touch less delicate.”
Two handling steps matter more than the ingredient list suggests. Fold the dough on itself 5 to 10 times before flattening, which Pallotta says “will make the cannoli shell lighter and full of little bubbles.” Then rest it, anywhere from 30 minutes covered up to Camila Hurst’s 4 hour minimum at Pies and Tacos, preferably overnight. The long rest belongs to the developer whose readers report the crispest shells.
Rolling the shells to 1 or 2 millimetres
Thin, then thinner than that. Pallotta aims for “about 1 to 2 millimetres.” Bialek gives approximately 1 mm and equates it to setting 6 on a pasta machine. Briones gives 1/16 inch, about 1.6 mm.
The yields tell you whether you got there. Hurst gets 40 cannoli out of a 2 cup flour dough, Pallotta gets 16 out of 200 g, Briones gets 12 to 15. A 2 cup dough producing a dozen shells was rolled several times too thick, and a thick shell fries into something closer to a doughnut. Cut the dough into 6 pieces before the pasta machine so the sheets stay manageable.

Shaping without cannoli tubes
The named failure is wrapping too tightly. Bialek: “DO NOT wrap the dough too tightly around them. Wrapping too tightly causes the dough to contract during frying and stick to the tubes.” In the process photographs the circle lies diagonally across the tube, the opposite edges lap by roughly 2 cm, and a gap shows between dough and metal along part of the length. That gap is correct.
Sealing the lap needs no egg. Nasoya uses “a small amount of drained silken tofu ‘juice’ to hold together to edges.” Briones uses aquafaba. Either is a thin sticky liquid brushed under the top flap.
Without tubes, the technique is real and the published instruction is thin. The only video I found where homemade forms are the subject rather than a footnote is Nate Bakes’, and his shell dough uses butter and eggs, so the forms transfer and the recipe does not. He gives no dimensions, and Britt Berlin at The Banana Diaries confirms the substitute exists while still telling readers to buy forms. So here is what I can honestly give you: match the steel. The tubes in the process photographs are straight sided, roughly 13 to 14 cm long and about 2 cm across, and the circles are cut about 9 cm wide. Build a foil cylinder to those proportions and oil it.

Frying at 350 to 360 degrees
The temperature is settled. Briones and Hurst fry at 350°F, Nasoya heats canola to 360°F, Pallotta gives 180°C and converts it to 360°F, and Bialek runs cooler at 340 to 350°F.
The time is not settled, and it is the one number I will not give you as a single figure. Pallotta says about a minute per cannolo, Briones about a minute per batch, Hurst 1 to 2 minutes per side, Nasoya 2 to 3, Bialek about 3. A reader on Briones’ page wrote: “However they were not done after frying for one minute. I read many other recipes after this and they all said 2-3 min. I wish I had gone longer.” Fry to the look instead: deep gold, blistered across the whole surface, firm enough to ring against the tongs.
USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service names the oils it considers safe for deep frying, “peanut, canola, corn, grape seed, safflower, sunflower, and vegetable,” with smoke points running 410 to 450°F, all well above the frying window. Work in small batches and let the oil climb back before the next one goes in. No source here puts a number on that recovery, so watch the thermometer rather than the clock. Developers who fry cool report greasy shells.
FSIS states the hazard in terms that apply directly to wet dough and wet tubes: “When water encounters very hot oil (about 350 F) water vaporizes instantaneously turning into super heated steam. It expands quickly, which can cause oil to splatter and risk bodily injury.” The same fact sheet notes frying oil can pass 400°F and recommends keeping a kitchen fire extinguisher to hand.
Baking is a real option with a real cost. Berlin bakes her shells at 400°F for 20 to 25 minutes, rolled thicker at about 1/8 inch, for a yield of 12. Hurst, asked about baking her own recipe, refused to guess: “I have never tried baking them… so I can’t vouch for the results.” A baked shell comes out thicker, less blistered and less rich.
Two component vegan cannoli recipe
Recipe: Vegan Cannoli
Ingredients, shells
- 1 1/2 cups (200 g) cake flour, or all purpose for a slightly sturdier shell
- 2 tablespoons (25 g) granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon dark cacao powder
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 2 tablespoons (25 g) vegan butter, softened
- 4 tablespoons (65 g) marsala or sweet red wine, or 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar mixed with 3 tablespoons water
- 1 tablespoon (15 g) water
- Aquafaba, or the liquid drained off silken tofu, for sealing the laps
- About 5 cups canola, peanut, sunflower, safflower, corn or grapeseed oil for frying
Ingredients, filling
- 14 oz extra firm tofu, drained and pressed
- 1 teaspoon white miso paste, or tahini
- 2 tablespoons olive oil
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 8 oz vegan cream cheese, softened
- 1 cup (120 g) powdered sugar
- Zest of 1 medium lemon, or of 1 orange
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/3 cup vegan mini chocolate chips
- To finish: coarsely chopped pistachios, candied orange peel, powdered sugar
Method
- Press the tofu. Its maker gives 10 to 15 minutes for extra firm; that is the floor, and a block still weeping water needs longer.
- Rub the vegan butter into the flour, sugar, cacao and cinnamon, add the wine and water, and work it to a firm smooth dough. Fold it on itself 5 to 10 times before flattening. Wrap and rest 30 minutes, or refrigerate up to overnight.
- Blend the pressed tofu with the miso, olive oil and salt until smooth. Add the cream cheese, powdered sugar, zest, vanilla and cinnamon, blend again, then fold in the chocolate chips by hand.
- Chill the filling at least 1 hour. Two is better, and it pipes more cleanly cold.
- Roll the dough to 1 to 2 mm, or setting 6 on a pasta machine, cutting the dough into 6 pieces first. Cut circles about 9 cm across.
- Lay each circle diagonally across an oiled tube and lap the opposite edges by about 2 cm. Leave it loose. Brush aquafaba or tofu liquid under the top flap and press only that seam.
- Heat the oil to 350 to 360°F. Fry a few at a time for 1 to 3 minutes, until deep gold and blistered all over. Let the oil come back to temperature between batches.
- Drain the shells on paper. When the tubes are cool enough to hold, twist each shell off to finish cooling.
- Pipe the filling into both ends just before serving. Press pistachios into one end, lay candied orange peel on the other, dust with powdered sugar.
To bake instead of fry, roll to about 1/8 inch and bake at 400°F for 20 to 25 minutes. The shells come out thicker and much less blistered.
The vinegar and water swap keeps the acid in the dough when you do not want to open a bottle of wine. Plain water on its own is what produces a soft shell.
Marsala and animal derived fining agents
Wine in the dough is the one place a vegan dessert can quietly stop being vegan. A peer reviewed review of allergenic proteins in enology, published in Molecules, records that egg white “binds with negatively charged compounds such as tannins” and that isinglass, from the “Air bladder of certain fish species,” is used in white wines “to clean up the aroma, improve clarity and modify the finish.” Those are processing aids, so they do not have to appear on the label. Check the bottle or the producer, and use the vinegar and water swap when you cannot. I will not name a marsala as safe, because nothing here establishes which producers fine with what. I will not tell you the alcohol all cooks off in the fryer either. One commenter says it does, and one home cook is not evidence.
Filling at the last minute
Every source in this research agrees on this one. Pallotta: “Fill just before serving.” Briones: fill “just before serving so they don’t get soggy.” Hurst and Gretchen say the same. Six developers, no dissent. Assembly is a serving step. Pipe them at the table if you can, because a tray of filled cannoli sitting out through an afternoon will be soft by the last row.
The finishes are optional and traditional: chocolate chips in the filling, chopped pistachios pressed into one open end, candied orange peel on the other, powdered sugar over the top. The rest of the pistachio bag goes into vegan pistachio ice cream.
When the shells go soft or the filling runs
- Shells soft instead of crisp. Check the liquid first: water rather than wine or a vinegar mix means there was no acid in the dough. Then check thickness and fry time.
- Shells that will not blister. Too thick, or no acid, or both. Roll to 1 to 2 mm and fold the dough 5 to 10 times before flattening.
- Shells that unrolled in the oil. The lap was not sealed, or the seal was brushed too wide. Seal only under the top flap.
- Shells stuck to the tube. Wrapped too tightly. Leave a visible gap between dough and metal.
- Greasy shells. Oil below temperature, usually because too many went in at once.
- Filling too loose to pipe. Chill it longer. Still loose after two cold hours means the base was not drained or pressed hard enough.
- Filling that tastes of tofu. That flavour is water and blandness. Press harder and sharpen it with citrus zest.
Making the shells and filling ahead
Separately, yes. Together, no. Louise answered a reader who asked exactly this: “Yes, you can absolutely make both components a couple of days in advance. Store the shells in an airtight container at room temp, and the ricotta in the fridge.” Briones puts a tighter figure on fried shells and says they can be made up to 12 hours ahead.
Storage claims for unfilled shells run from Hurst’s 3 days airtight through Pallotta’s 4 days, Gretchen’s week and Bialek’s 10 days to a few weeks on a non vegan shell. Those are texture observations by the people who made them rather than food safety findings, so plan around 3 to 4 days. For the filling, Pallotta says 4 days refrigerated and Gretchen says 10, same caveat.
Freezing is the question I cannot answer. The only freezer statement anywhere in this research is a developer telling a reader honestly that she had never tried it and was repeating something she had read. Make the shells the day before instead. For a dessert you can make on Sunday and serve on Thursday, one of the other vegan desserts and baking recipes here will hold better. Vegan chocolate chip cookies are the low effort version of that afternoon, and vegan cinnamon rolls are the other dough worth a morning.
Sources
- USDA FSIS, Deep Fat Frying and Food Safety
- USDA AMS, Glucono Delta-Lactone technical evaluation report
- Swinehart, Harris, Louvau and Feng, Food Safety Implications of Online Recipes for Preparing Soaked Nuts and Nut-Based Dairy Analogs, Food Protection Trends 44(1), 2024
- Penas, di Lorenzo, Uberti and Restani, Allergenic Proteins in Enology, Molecules
- House Foods America, Premium Tofu Extra Firm
- Tofutti Brands, Better Than Cream Cheese Plain
- Kite Hill, Plain Cream Cheese
- Nasoya, Homemade Vegan Cannoli
- Nico Pallotta and Louise, The Plant Based School, Vegan Cannoli Recipe
- The Plant Based School, Vegan Ricotta
- Jasmine Briones, Sweet Simple Vegan, Vegan Cannoli
- Camila Hurst, Pies and Tacos, Vegan Cannoli
- Britt Berlin, The Banana Diaries, Easy Baked Vegan Cannoli Recipe
- Gretchen, Gretchen’s Vegan Bakery, Vegan Cannoli Recipe
- Marie Pinto Bialek, Feeling Foodish, Italian Cannoli Shells
- ItaliaPlantBased, Vegan Homemade Cannoli Siciliani with ricotta
- Nate Bakes, How To Make Baked and Fried Cannoli Shells WITHOUT Tubes/Molds