Vegan Cheese Sauce Two Ways: Potato and Carrot or Cashew

A 2023 thread on r/veganrecipes asked for the best nacho cheese recipe and turned into an argument. One commenter backed a potato and carrot sauce and dismissed the alternative flat out: “Nut based sauces don’t have the right texture for nachos.” Two comments down, someone else pushed the same base harder: “Potato Carrot nacho cheese is where it’s at! I add jalapenos to mine for ultimate nacho-ness.” The most upvoted answers in that same thread were cashew recipes.

Both camps are right, because they are describing two different sauces. A vegan cheese sauce built on boiled potato and carrot behaves nothing like one built on soaked cashews. They blend differently, they sit on a chip differently, and they behave completely differently in the fridge four days later. I read fourteen published recipes while putting this page together and not one of them puts the two side by side, which is roughly why that thread went the way it did.

The wider question of why plant cheese sets the way it does is answered in the complete vegan cheese handbook. This page is about the pourable version only.

Two vegan cheese sauce bases compared

Pick by what you are pouring it over and by who is eating it.

The two bases, from the tested recipes in the sources below
Base Best for What to watch
Potato and carrot Nachos, broccoli, baked potatoes, anyone avoiding nuts Turns gluey if you keep blending, and sets hard cold
Cashew Dips, burritos, tacos, sauces you want thick and rich Needs a soak and a real blender, and costs more

The potato base is the cheap one and the allergy safe one, and it is the one to make for a plate of nachos. It also punishes you for over blending. The cashew base is richer, stays pourable when it comes out of the fridge, and needs planning because the nuts have to soak first. If you are cooking for a crowd with a nut allergy in it, the choice is made for you: the potato and carrot version is a dairy free cheese sauce with no nuts anywhere in it.

Two identical white bowls side by side, one holding glossy golden orange potato and carrot sauce and the other holding matte pale beige cashew sauce
The potato and carrot base is yellow and glossy. The cashew base is pale beige and matte, and thicker at the same temperature.

The nut free potato and carrot base

Three tested recipes and two video descriptions converge on roughly the same vegetable ratio. Chris Petrellese at Sweet Simple Vegan uses 2 cups of potato to 1 cup of carrot. Erika Fowler’s video description gives the same 2 to 1. Polyvegan Kitchen’s description gives 2 cups of potato to 1 cup of carrot plus half an onion in the pot. Nora Taylor at Nora Cooks runs slightly softer on the potato at 1 1/2 cups to 1 cup of carrot. Anywhere in that band works.

Boil the vegetables in salted water, which is Erika Fowler’s instruction and the one detail the blog recipes skip. Nora Taylor boils about 10 minutes to fork tender. Chris Petrellese simmers about 20 minutes for a bigger pot with cashews in it. Then comes the step that only appears in one video description in this entire set, from Polyvegan Kitchen: “Drain and Save boiled water to add to blender if needed.” That cloudy water carries starch and salt, so it thins the sauce without watering down the taste. Throwing it out and reaching for plain water later is the small avoidable mistake.

From there the published methods fork. Nora Taylor drains the hot vegetables straight into the blender with everything else and stops, with no stove step at all. Megan Gilmore at Detoxinista steams hers and blends it deliberately thin, telling you outright that the blended mixture will be runny, then cooks it with arrowroot or tapioca on the stove for 3 to 5 minutes until it thickens and whisks in plant milk to bring it back to where she wants it. Her route takes longer and gives you a thickness dial. The straight blend is faster and gives you whatever thickness the potatoes decided on.

Over blending turns the potato base gluey

One page out of the fourteen carries the warning that matters most here, and it is buried in a tips list. Chris Petrellese: “Don’t overblend! If you’ve over-mashed homemade mashed potatoes, you’ll know that doing so makes them gluey and unfavorable in texture. The same thing will happen if you overblend this potato-based nacho cheese. For best results, blend until just smooth.”

She gives a stopping cue rather than a number of seconds, and that is the honest way to give it. The mechanism is measured, though. Bai and colleagues, writing in the International Journal of Biological Macromolecules in November 2024, pulled the material sitting outside the cells in potato mashes and found starch made up 57.2 to 64.4 percent of it, and that the samples with the most escaped material were the stickiest. Blending ruptures potato cells and pushes starch out into the liquid, and free starch is what makes the result tacky. That study measured mashes with an instrument and never touched a blender, so treat it as the reason rather than as a timer.

A stainless spoon lifted from a blender jar holding a smooth domed oval of bright yellow potato and carrot sauce that coats the back of the spoon

The cashew cheese sauce base

Soaking is where the tested recipes disagree most, and every option is on the table. Richa Hingle at Vegan Richa soaks raw cashews in warm water for at least 15 minutes. Julie at The Simple Veganista covers hers in hot water for 5 minutes and calls soaking optional, with up to 2 hours in cool water if you want it. Nisha Vora at Rainbow Plant Life boils them for 15 minutes, or soaks overnight in cool water, or gives Vitamix owners 15 to 30 minutes in boiling water.

Reddit has the same argument. Under a 2026 thread, the recipe’s own author wrote: “You can skip the soaking step if you have a vitamix! Hope you enjoy.” A reader answered from experience: “I would still soak the cashews, I have a vitamix and I still soak the cashews for a creamier texture, any time I haven’t it isn’t the same.” Soak them.

Soak cashews in the fridge rather than on the counter. Purdue’s food safety researchers, writing in April 2024 about homemade nut based dairy analogs, list refrigerated soaking first among the steps that “significantly reduce the risk,” alongside hand washing and clean utensils. Illinois Extension puts the reason plainly: in some research, soaking for long periods or at room temperature increased the growth of salmonella bacteria, and their page adds that you should use pasteurized nuts. Neither source says a home method makes soaked nuts safe. They both say it lowers the risk.

The liquid ratio is what makes this base thick. Richa Hingle uses 1 cup of cashews to 1/2 cup of water plus more as needed. Julie gives 1/2 to 3/4 cup of water to 1 cup of cashews. Megan Gilmore’s six ingredient version goes down to 6 tablespoons of water per cup of cashews, which is why hers is a dip and not a pour. Start at half a cup and add from there.

Do not blend it once and walk away. Richa Hingle blends for a minute, checks, adds a tablespoon or two of water, blends 30 seconds, rests 5 minutes, blends 10 seconds, rests 2 minutes, then blends a final half minute. The rests let the cashew solids hydrate so the last pass can finish the job. That is the opposite of the potato rule. Extra time in the blender helps this base, and the rests are doing as much work as the blades.

Use a blender, not a food processor. On Minimalist Baker’s cashew page a reader reported processing the nuts a long time, adding the rest, and ending up with “the whole thing ended up in a tight ball in my processor,” which took three tablespoons of olive oil to loosen. Another on the same page got something closer to hummus than to a sauce. Both are equipment failures. Every tested source here uses a blender. If you want the thicker spreadable version of this base instead of a sauce, that is cashew cheese, which is a different job.

Seasoning a vegan cheese sauce

Nutritional yeast is the savory backbone in almost every version, and the amount is wide open. Richa Hingle uses 2 tablespoons in a cup of cashews. Megan Gilmore’s potato version uses 1/4 cup. Nora Taylor, Chris Petrellese and Erika Fowler all use 1/2 cup. Polyvegan Kitchen writes “1/2C nutritional yeast or more if you want more of a cheesy flavor. Taste and add as you go.” No source in this set names the point where it stops tasting like cheese and starts tasting like yeast, so I am not going to invent one. Start at a quarter cup for a potato batch, taste, and climb from there. Bragg, which makes the stuff, describes it as an inactivated version of the yeast used for bread or beer, with “a savory or umami flavor.”

If nutritional yeast is out, there are two named swaps. Richa Hingle: “An extra tablespoon of miso will give your cashew nacho cheese the umami flavor without needing nutritional yeast.” Monica Davis at The Hidden Veggies offers umami mushroom powder for a reader with a histamine intolerance, at about a teaspoon, with an honest caveat that “it doesn’t have as much of a cheesy flavor.” Reddit’s answers to the same question land on miso and on fermented tofu, used in small amounts.

Acid does more work than people expect. Every potato recipe here carries lemon juice, from a tablespoon up to the juice of a whole lemon. Pickled jalapeno brine is a seasoning in its own right and shows up as a measured ingredient in four of these recipes, not as a garnish. Richa Hingle names the combination that reads as nacho rather than as generic sauce: smoked paprika, onion, garlic, a pinch of cumin if you like, nutritional yeast, miso and pickled jalapeno brine together.

Color is a genuine split among people who test these for a living. Polyvegan Kitchen adds 1/4 teaspoon of turmeric purely for color to a batch built on 2 cups of potato. Megan Gilmore refuses: “I can’t bring myself to make this vegan nacho cheese sauce orange, because anything that turns it orange (like nutritional yeast or turmeric) might ruin the flavor.” That is her taste judgment about her own six ingredient recipe. Carrot does most of the color work in the potato base anyway.

Vegan cheese sauce recipe for both bases

Recipe: vegan cheese sauce, two bases

Prep
15 minutes, mostly a cashew soak
Cook
10 minutes for the potato base, none for the cashew base
Total
25 minutes
Yield
About 3 cups from the potato base, about 1 1/2 cups from the cashew base

Potato and carrot base

  • 2 cups peeled and diced potato
  • 1 cup peeled and diced carrot
  • Salted water to cover
  • 1 cup of the reserved cooking water to start, plus more to loosen
  • 1/2 cup nutritional yeast, or 1/4 cup if you want it milder
  • 3 tablespoons olive oil, or leave it out for an oil free version
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon onion powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon smoked paprika
  • 1/4 teaspoon turmeric, for color only

Cashew base

  • 1 cup raw cashews, unroasted and unsalted
  • 1/2 cup water, plus 1 to 2 tablespoons more as needed
  • 2 tablespoons nutritional yeast
  • 1 teaspoon yellow miso paste, or 1 tablespoon if you are leaving the nutritional yeast out
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1 tablespoon pickled jalapenos plus 1 tablespoon of their brine
  • 2 tablespoons salsa or chopped tomato
  • 1/2 teaspoon each smoked paprika, garlic powder, onion powder and salt
  • 1/8 teaspoon turmeric

Method

  1. For the cashew base, cover the cashews with warm water and soak in the fridge for at least 15 minutes. If you have time, soak them overnight in cool water in the fridge instead. Drain.
  2. For the potato base, put the potato and carrot in a pot, cover with salted water, bring to a boil and cook about 10 minutes, until a fork goes through easily. Drain over a bowl and keep the cooking water.
  3. Blend the drained vegetables with 1 cup of the reserved cooking water and all the potato base seasonings. Stop as soon as it is smooth. Blending past that point makes it gluey.
  4. Thin the potato sauce with more reserved cooking water, a tablespoon at a time, until it pours the way you want it.
  5. For the cashew base, blend the drained cashews with the water and all the cashew seasonings for a minute. Check it, add 1 to 2 tablespoons more water if it is too stiff, and blend 30 seconds. Rest 5 minutes, blend 10 seconds, rest 2 minutes, then blend a final half minute until it is creamy.
  6. To serve the cashew base warm, heat it gently in a small saucepan over low heat for about 8 minutes, stirring now and then. Add a splash of plant milk or water if it stiffens.

The potato base can be blended straight from the pot with no stove step, which is how Nora Cooks does it, or blended thin and then thickened on the stove with a tablespoon or two of arrowroot, tapioca or cornstarch, which is how Detoxinista does it. The second route gives you more control and takes 3 to 5 minutes longer. Neither base needs a starch to work.

Thickness targets for nachos and pasta

Not one of the fourteen pages I read states a target. They all say to add liquid as needed and leave you to guess what needed means.

Nacho thick means the sauce fills the bowl of a spoon and coats the back of it opaquely, and a lifted chip carries one heavy drip rather than a run. Poured over a plate, it spreads across three or four chips and then stops, holding a slightly domed edge where it pools. It does not sheet off the chip and it does not disappear into the plate.

Pasta loose means it comes off the lip of a jug as a thin unbroken ribbon about the width of a pencil, and the puddle levels out almost as soon as it lands. That is the version you want over broccoli or tossed through pasta, because it has to coat everything without gluing it together.

Adjust with water a tablespoon at a time. Sam Turnbull and Megan Gilmore both arrived at the same amount independently, and a tablespoon is small enough that you cannot overshoot in one go. For the potato base, use the reserved cooking water instead of plain water.

Two pours of the same yellow sauce photographed side by side, a narrow pencil width ribbon on the left and a thicker slower column on the right
The thin ribbon levels out as soon as it lands. The thicker column holds a small mound for a beat first.

Vegan queso from the same base

Queso is the nacho sauce with heat and tomato in it. Richa Hingle’s cashew version already gets there: pickled jalapeno and its brine, 2 tablespoons of salsa or chopped tomato, and half to a full teaspoon of chipotle chili flakes. Nisha Vora goes further and builds hers on 1/2 cup of salsa and 1/2 cup of unsweetened plain coconut yogurt with 2 tablespoons of pickled jalapenos and 2 tablespoons of their brine. On the potato base, stir the same additions in after blending so the tomato does not disappear into the color.

Nachos, broccoli, and baked potatoes

Nachos are the obvious one, and the potato base is the better pick there because it stays put on a chip. After that: steamed broccoli and cauliflower, baked potatoes, roasted vegetables, burritos and tacos, and small sandwiches like vegan sliders. If you want a spicy sliceable version instead of a sauce, that is vegan pepper jack cheese, and the rest of the vegan cheese recipes here cover the firm styles. For mushrooms, mashed potatoes, or a seitan steak, the pouring sauce to make is vegan peppercorn sauce. Vegan mac and cheese is its own recipe and gets its own page.

One honest limit for parties. Nothing in the tested sources covers holding a sauce warm for hours, so I am not going to pretend there is a method for it. The only sourced warming instruction is gentle low heat for about 8 minutes, and the FDA’s rule is that leaving perishable food out for 2 hours or more allows bacteria to multiply rapidly. Put out a bowl, refill it from the pan, and keep the clock in mind.

Reheating without splitting or setting solid

The potato base sets hard in the fridge. That is normal and it comes back. Monica Davis, whose starch based sauce does the same thing, puts it plainly: the sauce thickens significantly when cold, and it regains its melty texture when reheated. Her method is 1 tablespoon of water and a minute in the microwave, or about 3 minutes in a saucepan on the stove, whisking until it is smooth again. Megan Gilmore warns against boiling the potato base when you bring it back.

The cashew base thickens less and comes back faster. Nisha Vora’s instruction is 8 minutes over low heat with occasional stirring, plus a splash of plant milk or water if it seems too thick. Megan Gilmore gives the same single tablespoon of water for her cashew version.

There is a make ahead trick worth stealing from Detoxinista and it belongs to the potato base. Blend everything except the plant milk, keep that mixture in the fridge for up to 5 days, then pour it into a pan when you want it, bring it to a boil and stir until it thickens. Nobody else in this set offers that.

One failure I cannot explain, reported by a reader on The Hidden Veggies: stirring miso into an already thickened sauce turned it completely watery, twice, and simmering it again did not help. No source in this research gives a cause. If you are adding miso, add it early with the rest of the seasonings rather than into a finished sauce.

Storage windows for each base

The developers do not agree with each other. Megan Gilmore gives her cooked potato base 2 days. Nora Taylor gives hers 4 days. Chris Petrellese gives hers 7 days and 3 months in the freezer. Michaela Vais gives her tapioca sauce 2 days and says the texture changes anyway. That is a spread of 2 to 7 days for the same style of sauce, and none of those numbers is a food safety claim. They are texture and taste observations by the people who wrote the recipes.

The sourced number is shorter. The FDA’s refrigerator and freezer storage chart puts soups and stews made from vegetables at 3 to 4 days refrigerated and 2 to 3 months frozen, at a refrigerator running at 40 degrees F or below. University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension says the same thing for leftovers generally, 3 to 4 days in the fridge or 2 to 6 months frozen at 0 degrees F, and adds that food should be refrigerated within 2 hours. Use 3 to 4 days as the working window and treat the longer developer claims as their own experience.

Freezing the potato base is where the split is widest. Chris Petrellese freezes hers with a stated method: cool completely at room temperature, transfer to a freezer safe jar or bag, thaw in the fridge for 24 to 48 hours, then reheat in the microwave or on low on the stove. A commenter on that r/veganrecipes thread batch freezes it as a matter of routine. Michaela Vais says of her own starch based sauce that the texture changes after two days in the fridge, never mind a freezer. Freeze a small batch first and decide for yourself.

Sources